Italian Pie Shoppe Italian Pie Shoppe Italian Pie Shoppe
Home Page History Reviews Our Menu Party Menu Send us an email
Italian Pie Shoppe

Our Menu
Prices and menu items subject to change without notice.

Appetizers | Salads | Pasta | Sandwiches | Beverages
Award-Winning Pizza | Pie Shoppe House Specials
Specialty Pizza | Ala Carte | Desserts

CLICK HERE FOR A PRINTABLE
PDF VERSION OF THIS MENU.

Order Online!
APPETIZERS
Italian Fries with Cheese
Our flaky thin pizza crust folded in half and filled with mozzarella cheese, topped with garlic butter and our special spices. Served with dipping sauce. Add a pizza topping to our Italian Fries @ $0.75 each. Maximum 2 toppings.
$7.50
Brocchi
Our spectacular Italian fries filled with cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese and broccoli. Served with dipping sauce.
$7.99
Garlic Bread (Plenty to share!)
Fresh chopped garlic, butter and spices on oven baked bread. Side of sauce - $0.60
$2.99
Big Dipper (Plenty to share!)
Italian bread topped with melted mozzarella cheese, freshly chopped garlic and spices. Served with dipping sauce. Add a pizza topping to your dipper @ $0.75. Maximum 2 toppings.
$5.25

Mr. B's Anti Vampire Buffalo Wings!
Fabulous! Hot & spicy. Oven baked with fresh garlic. Add a side of Bleu Cheese Dressing - $0.60
Loaded with extra vampire sauce for an extra $0.49

$7.99
. : back to top : .
SALADS
Godfather Salad
Crisp green lettuce topped with pepperoni, ham, salami, cheese, green pepper, fresh tomato, and green olives. Served with a choice of dressing and Italian bread.
$7.29
Caesar Salad
With Romaine lettuce and Italian bread.
$6.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
With Romaine lettuce and Italian bread.
$7.99
Dinner Salad
Served with your choice of dressing.
$2.99
Dressings:
French, 1000 Island, Bleu cheese, Creamy Italian, Ranch, Rosie's Own Italian, Fat Free French or Ranch
. : back to top : .
PASTA
Spaghetti or Mostaccioli
Complete with two meatballs, our savory special sauce, bread, and dinner salad.
$7.49
Build Your Own Lasagna
Covered with meatless sauce and mozzarella cheese. Choose any of two pizza ingredients. Served with oven baked garlic bread and a dinner salad.
$7.99
Baked Spaghetti or Baked Mostaccioli
Smothered in homemade spaghetti sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese and baked in a pan. Served with oven baked garlic bread and a dinner salad.
Add a meatball or pepperoni to baked spaghetti or baked mostaccioli - $0.99
Substitute a Caesar salad for the dinner salad for an additional $1.75
$7.99
. : back to top : .
SANDWICHES
A unique style sandwich baked in our fresh pizza crust unless otherwise noted.
Hot Dago
Italian sausage patty (1/2 lb) between Italian bread with our own homemade spaghetti sauce.
$6.99
Pepperoni & Cheese Melt
Pepperoni with mozzarella cheese, fresh mushrooms, green pepper, freshly sliced tomatoes, and crisp lettuce. Served with side of spaghetti sauce.
$6.25
Sausage & Cheese Melt
Italian sausage patty (1/2 lb), melted mozzarella cheese & onions on Italian bread. Served with a side of spaghetti sauce.
$6.99
Ham & Swiss Cheese
Sliced ham and Swiss cheese with sliced tomatoes and crisp lettuce.
$6.25
Chicago Torpedo
Ham, salami, pepperoni, Swiss cheese, crisp lettuce, sliced tomatoes and our creamy Italian dressing on the side.
$6.25
Veggie
Green peppers, onions, olives, fresh mushrooms, sliced tomatoes, lettuce, Swiss cheese and our creamy Italian dressing.
$6.25
Meatballwich
Open-face meatball sandwich smothered with homemade spaghetti sauce on Italian bread.
$6.25
CALZONES & STROMBOLI
Calzone
Our fresh pizza crust filled with our homemade pizza sauce, spices, heaping mozzarella cheese and choice of two toppings. Additional toppings at $0.75 each. Maximum three toppings.
$7.49
Stromboli
Sliced ham, salami, Swiss cheese, black olives, onions, and creamy Italian dressing, oven baked in a flaky pizza crust.
$7.49
. : back to top : .
BEVERAGES
Coffee/Hot Tea/Milk $1.60
Soft Drinks, 16 oz.
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root beer. Add cherry or vanilla to any soft drink.
(includes one free refill)
$1.60
Lemonade $1.60
Ice Tea $1.60
Pitcher of Pop, 64 oz. $3.45
Beer and wine available
. : back to top : .
divider
ALA CARTE
Potato chips, 1.5 oz. $0.75
Sausage Patty $3.75
Extra meatball $0.99
. : back to top : .
divider
DESSERTS
Fresh baked cookies and brownies
. : back to top : .
AWARD-WINNING PIZZA
Thin Crust Pizza
Small Cheese, 10"
Extra ingredients - $1.50 each
$7.99
Large Cheese, 14"
Extra ingredients - $2.50 each
$11.49
Extra-Large Cheese, 17"
Extra ingredients - $2.75 each
$13.99
Deep Dish or Stuffed Pizza
Small Cheese, 8"
Extra ingredients - $1.50 each
$7.99
Medium Cheese, 10"
Extra ingredients - $2.00 each
$10.49
Large Cheese, 12"
Extra ingredients - $2.50 each
$13.99
PIE SHOPPE HOUSE SPECIALS
Build Your Own 14" thin crust
Pick any three pizza ingredients.
$17.99
Build Your Own 12"
(deep or stuffed crust)

Pick any three pizza ingredients.
$18.99
Special Six Item Combo
(Thin crust only)
Includes Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black or green olives.
Small (10")
$14.99
Large (14") $19.99
Extra-Large (17") $22.99
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
Sorry, no substitutions on specialty pizzas.
Please allow 30 minutes for a deep dish and 20 minutes for a thin crust. To ensure proper cooking, there is a limit of 5 ingredients on a deep dish and 4 ingredients on a stuffed pizza.
Margherita
Thin crust only.
Olive oil, mozzarella cheese, pizza sauce, special spices and diced tomatoes.

10"–$8.49

14"–$13.99

17"–$16.99

Original White Pizza
Thin crust only.
Olive oil, fresh garlic, special spices & mozzarella cheese, served hot on our famous thin crust.
10"–$7.99

14"–$11.99

17"–$14.99

Additional pizza toppings. Maximum six. Price for each. $1.50 (10") / $2.50 (14") / $2.75 (17")
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (Thin Crust)
Our homemade crust topped with chicken, Mr B's anti vampire sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Hot and spicy!
Small (10")
$9.99
Large (14") $14.99
Extra-Large (17") $17.99
Barbecue Chicken Pizza (Thin Crust)
Our homemade crust topped with barbecue sauce, chicken, onions, and mozzarella cheese.
Mmmmm good!!
Small (10")
$9.99
Large (14") $14.99
Extra-Large (17") $17.99
Spinach Pizza (Deep Dish or Stuffed)
Another Chicago favorite! A special mixture of fresh spinach, diced tomatoes and mozzarella cheese blended with herbs and spices with our rich pizza sauce and a light flaky deep pan crust.
(Thin crust available upon request.)
Small (8")
$9.49
Medium (10") $12.49
Large (12") $15.99
South of the Border (Deep Dish)
Italian sausage or chicken, black olives, onions, with a blend of cheese and mild taco sauce. Baked in a deep pan crust. Topped with lettuce and tomatoes.
(Thin crust available upon request.)
...with Italian Sausage
Small (8")
$10.49
Medium (10") $13.49
Large (12") $17.99
...with Chicken
Small (8")
$10.99
Medium (10") $14.29
Large (12") $18.99
Vegetarian (Deep Dish or Stuffed)
A flaky deep pan crust topped with broccoli, zucchini, black olives, onions, fresh mushrooms, diced tomatoes and special spices.
(Thin crust available upon request.)
Small (8")
$11.99
Medium (10") $14.99
Large (12") $18.99
Meat Lover Combo (Deep Dish or Stuffed)
Italian sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, salami, mozzarella cheese, diced tomatoes, and special spices baked in our light flaky deep dish crust.
(Thin crust available upon request.)
Small (8")
$11.99
Medium (10") $14.99
Large (12") $19.99
. : back to top : .

CLICK HERE FOR A PRINTABLE VERSION OF THIS MENU.

Prices and menu items subject to change without notice.

Appetizers | Salads | Pasta | Sandwiches | Beverages
Award-Winning Pizza | Pie Shoppe House Specials | Specialty Pizza | Ala Carte | Desserts

. : back to top : .

Go Ask Rob